Bruce Baugh: Like Unto a Sage
Nov. 6th, 2004 01:32 amBruce Baugh is an sf and rpg fan and writer who has been, for many years, an online friend and one of the people in my mental catalog of "proof that not all libertarians are moonbat assholes". (The not-quite-exhaustive list also includes Jim Henley,
In a short essay some time ago (sorry, no link readily to hand) Bruce was responsible for introducing me to the concept of "regulatory capture", about which I hope to write more soon; it's one of the few concepts of politics to which I was introduced by libertarians which strikes me as both terrifically important and not obvious. In short, regulatory capture is the process in which an industry which is regulated by the government will eventually traduce the regulatory scheme and turn it to the industry's advantage. Obvious recent examples are the consolidation of the broadcast media thanks to subversion of the FCC and the $600 billion big pharma boondoggle known as the Medicare Prescription Drug Plan.
So imagine my surprise to learn that Bruce has abandoned libertarianism. Imagine my pleasure to discover him writing the words in my head:
This is where I break most decisively, I think, with the idea that the big priority is to work for a reduction of state power. I agree that it would be well to have a smaller, much more tightly bounded and governed state. But I also think that the way the state operates matters: the sort of social stability that Hayek describes as crucial for the useful operation of markets calls for honesty, consistency, competence, and other virtues in government. The thing is, making that happen requires serious, detailed engagement with the operations of government. You have to find representatives interested in the subject, and staffers who can do the job right, and there are volunteer positions that gotta be staffed, and oversight, and a whole lot of things that can't be done by people who are standing aloof casting aspersions on the whole thing.
Thanks for saying it so well, Bruce. Thanks for being here, now.
(Pointer courtest of Electrolite. I read Bruce's blog, but I hadn't realized he'd updated recently because the BlogLines read of his RSS feed is flakey.)